Personal Blog Top Sites

Tuesday, August 09, 2005

Life is a Jam

“...in a consort of instruments, we do not hear the lute, the spinet and the flute, but a global harmony, the fruit resulting from the combination of the entire group.” -Michel De Montaigne from “On Friendship” (Pg. 46)

-Good musicians, like good citizens, listen to others and have the chops and good sense to figure out not how best to make themselves shine, but how best to blend with the others to create a beautiful harmony and make a good song better. Such is the same with life. We must all learn how best to contribute to sustaining life on earth as long as possible, while enjoying the fruit of our contributions.

Let me first state, that I believe there are two kinds of players of instruments, as there are also two kinds of citizens. First, there are musical automatons, those who have been trained how to play what they are told. Then, there are musicians who have been educated and disciplined in the art of making music.

The world is very much like Michel De Montaigne’s consort of instruments...each person playing their part. Our job is to perfect our chops and learn how to listen to others so that we may contribute to the consort in a harmonious way...improving on the song, without distracting from it, or attracting attention to ourselves or, in other words, without attempting to outshine but shine with each other.

If you’ve ever heard a good “jam-session”, the “song” probably went on forever...morphing and segueing from different stages of blend...all the players contributing without dragging the song down by trying to steal the show. When a musician decides to try to outshine the others...the jam is pretty-much over, because the other musicians lose interest for one reason or another (perhaps, they don’t feel a need to support and inflate another’s ego) or perhaps they add too much.

A good, true, jam-session is one where there is no rank, no star to shine with need of support. A good jam has everyone shining together in an endless blending morph of harmonies. You hear, as Montaigne says, “the fruit resulting from the entire group.”

One aspect of a good jam I’d like to focus on now is this:

When this magical amalgamation of sound occurs...the song can go on forever. It dosn’t ever get boring...it doesn’t lose too much energy or get over-bearing. The musicians always know how to keep the song alive through balance, and tasteful contribution. They know how to sustain the life of the song through sharing contributions. They listen to each other and add just exactly what is needed...always moving forward and falling back whenever it’s called for, thus pushing and moving the song through various phases, always improving and adding to what was laid down before them, in just the right way.

Now, that being said, to be able to do this requires major chops. (Chops in musician-speak meaning skill, or talent.)

Let’s take a moment to elaborate a bit on what this means. There are many levels of skill and talent. First, to be a good player, you have to get the basic skill of your instrument, but to do so, takes good ears and imagination. First, you have to be able to hear and repeat a note acurately without going either sharp or flat. Then, you have to learn how to read or play by ear, or both. Then you have to study all the different keys, time signatures and technicalities (music theory). Having learned all this, you have achieved technical skill, and are now ready to graduate to the level of an automaton.

However, to be a good jam musician, you have to have more than just technical skill, you also have to study style, finess, dynamics, etc. Good jam musicians are also well versed. They don’t just study one genre of music or copy one musicians style. They listen to everything...and become well versed in the other instruments as well. They are sponges of music. But, they don’t just absorb and regurgitate, they absorb things to make it a part of who they are, and use it to contribute to the jams in a new and improved way. The best of them can even play other instruments with at least an average skill-level. They have to be this well versed if they are going to know where they are going to fit in with relation to the other instruments.

Jam musicians have to be able to empathise with the other instruments so that they can know just what they can do to add to a jam without bringing it all down. To be able to empathise, you must understand what it’s like to be in another musicians shoes. The best way to understand this, is to study it.

Now, since all musicians are human, they are sometimes bound to make mistakes. Afterall...nothing in the physical world is perfect. Perfection only exists in the abstract world of mathematics. Good musicians, however, know how to use these mistakes to the advantage of the “consort”, or the whole...and to the advantage of the “jam” in general. They can use those “mistakes” to move the song forward, perhaps even move it in another direction. Other musicians in the jam, if they are of the same calliber, will be able to go with the flow and move with each other’s mistakes. They don't stop playing, and become critical of another player. A good consort doesn’t drop the ball, because there’s no such thing as a dropped ball...only one that’s bounced in a different direction...to the benefit of all.

So, to reiterate...without beating a dead horse...good jam musicians first educate and discipline themselves, they listen and interact with each other, and support each other with the ultimate goal of sustaining the “song” for as long as possible.

I think this makes a reasonably good analogy for being a good citizen of the world.

We can either train ourselves to be automatons, doomed to simply regurgitate what we are told, rehashing history, or we can educate and discipline ourselves to add to the harmonious consort of instruments in an attempt to imrove and sustain the song (world) as long as possible.

7 Comments:

Blogger Jez said...

I was wondering what you were getting at! As usual, makes sense. Sometimes, I feel depressed and frustrated at the lack of 'good jamming' out there, and then I remember my Tokyo buddies, and I'm a utopian once more!

Saturday, August 13, 2005 8:12:00 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

I had an interesting association reading this - a direction that did not get addressed. You and I (and earlier Jez) live in Japan. Thinking about the structure of this society before things really started to change during the Meiji Restoration is a pretty accurate reflection of a society of trained muscial technicians. The citizens had a designated role that they were to know and to keep - stepping out of line (out of one's caste) might have been a fatal act of "jamming."

I can then think of other attempts in society that allowed people to jam - most resently the remnants of the IMF's attempts at nation destroying in Argentina. I am refering to the assemblies (impromptu councils of neighbourhood citizens gathering to democratically address their needs) that sprung up and perhaps still exist after the IMF succeeding in ruining the country. An interesting side note to that story is the immediate resistance that the citizen's faced from the old guard - those who wanted the conductor to control the orchestra.

Of course, for the societies that the three of us live in (and/or came from), we are told to innovate then build a mini-empire in the form of a tyrannical private organisation in which we have our own underlings to obey our conducting. If we can't do that, we are to accept "the realities of human nature" - that there are leaders and followers and we are followers. That's just the way it is.

I (as Scott) suggest a different path. Why not cooperate? No matter your lot in life. For example, I saw a council meeting of homeless people in the park yesterday (Scott, too) - yes, a council of homeless. They were meeting to discuss what needed to be done and how it was to get done. No one was the Commander In Chief, there was no bailiff. It was just a bunch of men deciding what needed to be done and how to do it.

We need our daily bread. Why, oh why don't we cooperate to get it? At my place of employment, people come in and beg the boss to let them have a subordinate position in his mini-empire and follow his show. What the hell are we doing? All the talent to get our work done is there. Why is it that we continue with the status quo instead of pooling our resources to create our own democratic workspace where the ultimate goal is not enriching the top man but furthering our craft in a way that all are treated equitably?

I suggest this: wherever you are, get together with your circle and create your own space. You need jobs? Create your own coop business whatever that particular business may be. (Just to show you examples, workers from a closed down aluminum mine in Quebec that the owner had abandoned, taking inspiration from similar actions in Argentina, went in and took over the mine, reopened it and quickly started turning a profit.

I'm not saying that you should annex some existing business. I am saying that if you are working a shit job in some restaurant, for example, why not find some people who would rather make more money and have better working conditions working in a democratic coop and open your own restaurant?

Sunday, August 21, 2005 3:08:00 PM  
Blogger Scott A. Meister said...

Hey guys, thanks again for the contributions.

Jez...I, like you, am depressed and frustrated at the lack of "good jamming" out there. That's what inspired this piece. However, I realized, that just because the rest of the world isn't into jamming, doesn't mean that I can't find some good people to jam with on my own.

In the process, perhaps the fruits of our jam will influence others to do the same. Y'know...the whole "lead by example" business.

djeb-Thanks for the interesting addition. I must admit, I was thinking in more general terms, and was trying to focus on the fact that to avoid becoming a slave or an automaton to be taken advantage of by others...we must first educate ourselves, and then learn to listen to our fellow citizens so that we can contribute in an intelligent way to the consort.

However, after reading your comment, I realized another thing that was not addressed in the piece.

A lot of people don't know how to cooperate, because they've been told that being a cog in the machine is the thing to do. If you think about it, it's really a lot easier to just do what your told. You don't have to take responsibility for the things that happen in your life, and you don't have to take chances. If something bad happens it's easier to blame the conductor, or the writer of the music. Jamming, requires taking risks, and a lot of people just aren't willing to do that. People, especially when they get older, enjoy a certain sense of security. Having someone else in charge, in this case, takes a load off your back. However, we were given a load to carry when we were born, we shouldn't be lazy, and try to ditch that responsiblity.

Furthermore, I have to add that people are afraid to take these chances because they are taught to fear. Everywhere you turn in society, there are people telling you to fear for the future. Fear of being ugly, fear of a spider that might or might not bite you, fear of not fitting in, fear of being oppressed for believing something that doesn't fit the norm, fear of criticism for attempting something never done before, fear of economic failure, fear of losing your loved ones for taking chances of anykind, fear of the unknown, and fear of failure.

Fear has paralyzed society.

You can't jam unless you are willing to take chances. Afterall, a jam session doesn't have sheet music. We in life, were not handed a sheet of music to play when we were born, we were born to take chances and deal with what we were given. If we can't get used to that...well, then what do we have?

Any further constructive comments are, as usual, most welcome.

Tuesday, August 23, 2005 2:27:00 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

I was thinking in more general terms, and was trying to focus on the fact that to avoid becoming a slave or an automaton to be taken advantage of by others...

What truly frightens me is how there are plenty of people out there who are more than happy to play their role, more than happy to follow the leader. For example, consider the debate that was over before it began: If I had a nickel for every time I debunked the case for the war in Iraq and another one for every time the debate partner threw back official propaganda at me. (In the next stage, they insult me or try to character assassinate my sources before they know they are beaten and run away to make the same debunked claims in the next argument.) There are people who are proud to be atomatons and are very passionate about repeating exactly what their masters want them to.


If you think about it, it's really a lot easier to just do what your told. You don't have to take responsibility for the things that happen in your life, and you don't have to take chances. If something bad happens it's easier to blame the conductor, or the writer of the music. Jamming, requires taking risks, and a lot of people just aren't willing to do that.

I just wanted to see that in print again. I agree wholeheatedly - there's nothing more I can add to that.


I have to add that people are afraid to take these chances because they are taught to fear.

Cooperation. I understand this. As we hit a low energy future, we are all going to face a lot of changes in our lives. I think we are all going to have to build "tribes" to survive what is coming. I'm only 36, but I have a lot of fear about my old age, but the only way out I see is through cooperation on a very local level. For example, there are a good number of seniors out there who care for each other in coop housing. Here in Japan, they are going to have to figure the same thing out, or they are screwed.

losing your loved ones for taking chances of anykind

How did you know my wife was so pi-issed that I was taking another permaculture course???

Tuesday, August 30, 2005 6:15:00 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

I hear you regarading the "Jam sessions" that are just so good they could go on...

I venture to add another kind of musician. The musician that just feels it. It's a natural expression that's not so much honed and practiced as it is innate.

Recommend: Weather Report's "Birdland"

Thursday, September 01, 2005 11:56:00 PM  
Blogger Scott A. Meister said...

Lauren,

So true, there are those musicians who can just feel it, yet they have all had the blessing of an open mind (and ears) and the a natural drive to educate themselves. It of course starts with that innate feeling, but what they do with that feeling from the beginning is what really counts. Those musicians have also had another important thing which I forgot to mention...nurturing and encouragement from those around them. Again, the same holds true with good citizenry, some people just get it...some don't. Those that get it, have a responsibility to nurture those that don't.

Love your recommendation by the way. I used to listen to that non-stop until I was introduced to CAN, specifically the song Bel Air from their album Future Days. I quite literally put that vinyl on the turntable with the repeat arm going non-stop for about three days. My room-mate didn't get sick of it either. It was a very nice few days. It ended when we both decided to go back to work, and save the vinyl from wearing completely out.

It would be great to hear more personal jam recommendations from everyone out there.

DJEB, certainly your wife isn't so pi-issed, that you're going to lose her! Besides, even if she was, I think you have the skills of logic and debate to explain the reasons why,, and she is reasonable enough to understand why you're doing that.

Money spent on educating yourself is almost always money well spent. (keeping moderation in mind of course...over consumption always leads to waste of some kind, right?)

Friday, September 02, 2005 8:54:00 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Scott,

Spam removed and verification code added. No more spam bots...

Monday, October 31, 2005 10:24:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home